Wednesday 1 April 2015

Invisibility

Yesterday was "International Transgender Day of Visibility". I attended a presentation/discussion at the university here, and it was nice to see the turn out for a part of it. However, it brought to light something the trans community, here at least, is lacking and it also brought to light an emotion I have had all of my life. One I knew was there but was too depressed to think about it reasonably because as is, it brings me down all on it's own. So, for a little warning, this won't be a happy post.

When I was a kid, when we all are kids, what is one of the main things we do socially? We look around for like minded people and we attach ourselves to them, or I guess you attach yourselves to each other. It's more or less the bases of friendship. We don't even realize what we are doing, we just gravitate toward each other. For me it was DnD, Dungeons and Dragons that brought myself and my friends together.

I vaguely remember how it happened. I was always into those sort of games, I would play rpg games on my computer or whatever console I had at the time, when I was even younger still I used to enjoy pretending I was a superhero or something with my friends who were also pretending to be superheroes and we'd beat of the invisible bad guys together.

I spent grade 8 being quite popular in school but when the summer came around and we weren't going to school all of my friends vanished, mainly because of geography, so no I'm not placing blame or accusations on them or me. But when I got to grade 9 my popularity of the previous year was gone, something I didn't really take conscious notice of. But for the most part, it was easy to tell from an outside observer that I had little to no friends. I spent my lunch times sitting in my classroom and looking outside at all the people doing whatever they do at lunch. I was always lost in my thoughts, even back then. In fact being lost in my thoughts back then was one of the main contributors of my depression that I was rapidly slipping into as grade 9 went on.

So one day two boys approached me, I have no idea what brought them over to me at all. Pity, interest, the logistical need for another player, I just don't know. But they asked me if I would like to play DnD with them and I quickly accepted. What that led to was a long relationship with the two of them and others that I still have today, as tenuous as they may be.

Not that I wanted to, but I was powerless to turn away their offer. I had just started to get a vague idea of how "messed up" I was, I had no friends and suddenly here were two people asking me to being their friend, more or less. How could I have said no? They made me feel like maybe I wasn't so messed up, of course until my depression completely took over. I lived two lives back then. The one that was a friend to these other kids, I laughed and joked with them, occasionally fought even but our friendships became so strong that even fights wouldn't ruin it. And the other life that had desires, feelings and emotions that conflicted directly with the person I presented to everyone else. That split is what ultimately led to my completely insane depression. I would come home from school, go straight to my room and cry until supper time and then I'd go back to my room and cry until bed time. I did this literally every day for 7 or 8 months. I unconsciously realized that being around my friends kept this level of depression more or less at bay. I put more mental energy into them than myself while they were around, so I spent as much time with them as I could.

Even with such good friends as these, ultimately I felt alone. My main "hate myself" thought was that I was messed up and no one liked me, the real me. The dance I did every moment of my life was exhausting, and dancing with yourself is as sad in reality as the imagery suggests. I had plenty of people to explain how I wanted to make my next DnD character to, but not a single person in my life that I could explain how I was feeling to. Someone else who also had my feelings seemed impossible. I was the only one who felt like me, I was the only one on the planet that wanted to do the things to my body that I did.

Fast forward to yesterday, it was during a talk among 16-20 people that I realized the same is true for me now, and I can't help but feel it is true for many older trans people. As I mentioned I was at the university here, and of course all of the people there were university students, of which I am not one and was the oldest person there by 10 years or more. I went there with the intentions of offering support to what I knew was going to be a young group. While sitting there though, I couldn't help but notice how there is plenty of support for young trans people. These peer support groups, a trans-friendly/lgbt oriented summer camp, housing and support for homeless trans under 25 etc. The two biggest hurdles a young trans person has now is themselves, and simply locating these services. It is fantastic for them, I can't imagine how my life would have changed were these things around when I was young and totally lost.

But...

There is nothing, absolutely nothing, for trans adults. If you are over 25, you're fucked, time to fend for yourself. I guess the mentality is after 25 you're a "real" adult and should be able to take care of yourself. Well, this may come as a shock, but being alone is no good at any age. I know exactly zero trans people my age, and not for lack of looking, trust me. everywhere I go, no matter how trans-friendly they are, I am the transgender flag bearer. I represent the transgender world to them because none of them are trans themselves and if I do end up in a situation like yesterday when I'm surrounded by transgender people, I am still a transgender flag bearer, I'm the future that these young men and women are looking at.

Just once I'd like to sit down with someone who is my age, roughly my intellect, conversation ability and just let go of everything to them. To someone that isn't going to be surprised or deflated with how hard my life still is. Someone who knows, because they have felt it, how being transgender paints and accentuates every decision you make and thought in your mind, or how inhibiting it can be, even on good days. How I feel years behind everyone else, years behind where I should be at my age.

Similar interests and values are great between friends. They can even make strong friendships. Having no one in your life you can truly connect to will always weigh in on the side of loneliness however. Imagine being the only women you've ever met. The only other females you've met are kids. Sure you have plenty of attention from all of the men around, and are probably looked up to by these kids, but there is no one you can turn too that doesn't make you feel like you're fencing with them. Everyone you speak to has no idea at all of where you are coming from, by design rather than fault, and their expressions of sympathy or encouragement are more or less useless to you because they cannot take into account you or your experiences/values/morals.

I can't really end off with a point because I don't have one. I just needed to get this out somehow.

2 comments:

  1. Ouch! This one was from the heart! I know what you mean, but I wonder if you’re looking for connection in the wrong direction.

    We tend to think that trans people form a “community”, just like gays, or lesbians, or people of colour. But the truth is that none of these are “communities” in any real sense. Sure they each have one thing in common, and since that thing does not affect the majority of people (straight white folks who’ve never given their assigned gender a second thought) the thing identifies them as members of a distinct minority. But it’s only one thing, one point of commonality between what may otherwise be completely different people (different backgrounds, different values, different ages, different needs and so on). We need to band together from time to time in order to defend our rights, push society’s boundaries and generally get our voices heard, but why should we assume that talking to another trans person, even if roughly of the same age, intellect or outlook, will somehow be better than talking to anyone else?

    We might like to think that another trans person would, at the very least, understand where we’re coming from and empathise with some of the issues we face. But I don’t think I have met another trans person who does understand me; hell, I don’t understand me. It took me decades before I finally wised up and stopped trying to figure out why I’m trans - there is no answer, no explanation. I just am, and trans people just are.

    So, from a personal perspective, I’ve given up on looking for “understanding”, either from myself or others. What I look for in others is acceptance - that blind, unquestioning acceptance that means my gender is as much a nonissue in any given situation as it is for non-trans people. And if that acceptance is there, then the standard rules will apply, and similar interests and values will lead to valuable and sometimes cherished connections.

    Minorities are, by and large, invisible, and if an individual chooses to primarily self-identify by reference to a minority group then he or she will be invisible too. In your case, it is clear from the quality of your writing that being trans is probably the least interesting thing about you. Accept yourself, look for acceptance in others, and concentrate on finding those with similar interests and values to you regardless of whether they have gender issues.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yeah, I was in a bit of an emotional state yesterday when I wrote this. I almost wish I didn't, but oh well.

    I more or less agree with you, and I hope I didn't give off the impression that I'd rather a trans friend my age over the rest of my friends, I'd just like one along with the rest of my friends. Just to have someone that can lend that completely understanding ear that really no one else can give. There are a few things a trans person in my position that younger trans people don't have to deal with so much, like the lost time I have mentioned before. That would have to be someone specifically who also didn't come out until their later ages, not just a trans person who is my age and transitioned 20 years ago.

    I guess I am kinda asking for a bit of a unicorn, hey?

    And btw this:

    " In your case, it is clear from the quality of your writing that being trans is probably the least interesting thing about you."

    Is one of the nicest compliments I have ever gotten, both to my personhood and my writing ability. Thank you very much.

    Rebecca

    ReplyDelete